Vladimir Putin has Redrawn the World but not the way he Wanted

Vladimir’s Putin’s invasion of Ukraine has changed the world. We are living in new and more dangerous times – the post-Cold War era that began with the fall of the Berlin Wall is over.

It is a rare thing to live through a moment of huge historical consequence and understand in real time that is what it is.

In November 1989, I stood on a snow-flecked Wenceslas Square in Prague, the capital of what was then Czechoslovakia, and watched a new world being born.

The peoples of Communist Eastern Europe had risen in defiance of their dictatorships. The Berlin Wall had been torn down. A divided Europe was being made whole again.

In Prague, the dissident playwright Vaclav Havel addressed a crowd of 400,000 from a second-floor balcony. It was an exhilarating moment, dizzying in its pace. That evening, the Communist regime collapsed and within weeks Havel was president of a new democratic state. I sensed, even at the time, that I had watched the world pivot – that it was one of those rare moments when you know the world is remaking itself before your eyes.

Vaclav Havel addresses thousands of demonstrators gathered on Prague’s Wenceslas Square, 24 November 1989.

How many such moments had there been in the history of Europe since the French Revolution? Probably, I thought then, about five. This, 1989, was the sixth.

But that world – born in those dramatic popular revolutions – came to an end when Putin ordered Russian forces into Ukraine.

The German Chancellor Olaf Scholz called this moment a zeitenwende – a turning point – while UK Foreign Secretary Liz Truss said it was a “paradigm shift”. The age of complacency, she said, was over.

Pivotal moments in Europe’s history

• Storming of the Bastille,14 July 1789
• 1789: French Revolution. Monarchy overthrown, republic founded
• 1815: Congress of Vienna redraws map of Europe, restores balance of power and ushers in decades of peace after the upheaval of the Napoleonic wars
• 1848: A wave of liberal and democratic revolutions across Europe
• 1919: Treaty of Versailles. New independent sovereign nation states replace old multi-national empires
• 1945: Yalta – great powers agree to partition Europe into Western and Soviet “spheres of influence”. Iron Curtain falls across the continent
• 1989: Democratic revolutions in Soviet-dominated Eastern Europe tear down the Iron Curtain. The Soviet Union collapses two years later. Vladimir Putin calls this the “greatest catastrophe of the 20th Century.

Quentin Sommerville, one of the BBC’s most experienced war reporters walked through the wreckage in Kharkiv recently and said of the Russian bombardment: “If these tactics are unfamiliar to you, then you haven’t been paying attention.”

He should know, he spent enough time under Russian rockets in Syria to be paying very close attention. But the governments of the democratic world – how much attention have they been paying to the nature of the Putin regime?

The evidence has been building for years.

Two decades have passed since he sent troops into Georgia claiming he was supporting breakaway regions.

Later, he sent spies into British cities armed with nerve agents to murder exiled Russians.

In 2014, he invaded Eastern Ukraine and annexed Crimea.

‘If these tactics are unfamiliar to you, then you haven’t been paying attention’

‘Suburban gardens have become battlefields from Europe’s past’.

Despite all this, Germany, and much of the EU, were locking themselves into an unhealthy dependence on Russian gas. A year after the annexation of Crimea, they approved the building of a new pipeline, Nord Stream 2, to boost supplies.

The “complacency” Liz Truss refers to also indicts her own country. London has been a safe haven for Russian money since John Major was prime minister. Russian oligarchs have parked billions here, laundered their money, bought up the most prestigious private homes in the capital, socialised with politicians and donated to their campaign funds. Few questions were asked about where their vast wealth, acquired so suddenly, had come from.

So, no. The Western democracies have not been “paying attention” to the nature of the menace that has been incubating on their eastern frontier.

But Putin, too, has seemed complacent.

Receiving station for the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, near Lubmin, Germany, March 2022.

Receiving station for the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, near Lubmin, Germany

First, he believed the West was in chronic decline, weakened by internal division and ideological rancour. The election of Donald Trump and Brexit he saw as proof of this. The rise of right-wing authoritarian governments in Poland and Hungary was further evidence of the disintegration of liberal values and institutions. The US’s humiliating withdrawal from Afghanistan was proof of a waning power withdrawing from the world stage.

Second, he misread what was happening on his borders. He refused to believe that a series of democratic uprisings in former Soviet Republics – Georgia (2003), Ukraine (2004-5) and Kyrgyzstan (2005) – could possibly be authentic expressions of the popular will. Because each was aimed at removing corrupt and unpopular pro-Moscow governments, it seemed self-evident to the Kremlin that these were the work of foreign intelligence agencies, the Americans and the British in particular – Western imperialism’s forward march into territory that was rightfully and historically Russia’s.

Third, he has failed to understand his own armed forces. It is clear now that he expected this “special military operation” to be over in a few days.

Russia’s military incompetence has astonished many Western security experts. It brings echoes for me of a smaller, more containable, but nonetheless devastating war, in former Yugoslavia.

In 1992, Serb nationalists launched a war to strangle the newly independent state of Bosnia at birth. They argued that Bosnian identity was bogus, that Bosnian statehood had no historical legitimacy, that it was really part of Serbia. It is exactly Putin’s view of Ukraine.

A Bosnian special forces soldier and civilians come under fire from Serbian snipers, Sarajevo, 6 April 1992.

A Bosnian special forces soldier and civilians come under fire from Serbian snipers, Sarajevo, 6 April.

Source-BBC